2014
J.D. Dotson, Centre College
Xavier Forrest, Samford
D'Andre Ferby, Western Kentucky University
Parker Wade, Navy
2015
Daniel Davis, Centre College
Myles Douglas, Tennessee Tech
Thomas Freeland, Washington and Lee
Trent Holt, Georgetown College
Brycen Hopkins, Purdue
Greg McCloud, East Tennessee State University
Rico McGraw, University of Georgia
P.J. Settles, Rhodes College
Donovan Sheffield, Vanderbilt University
Hunter Travis, Tennessee Tech
2016
Colby Green, Tennessee State University
Blake Mitchell, Mississippi State University
Darius Morehead, Furman University
2017Jarquis Hendricks, University of the Cumberlands
Rodney Owens, University of Louisville
Taylor Smith, Rhodes College
Nathaniel Taylor, Rhodes College
Jaylan Theus, Howard University
2018
Tanner Antonutti, University of Tennessee
Henry Byrd, Princeton University
Nicky Clifton, Syracuse University
Jaylon King, Georgia Tech
Paxton Smith, Denison University
2019William Garrett, Sewanee, The University Of The South
Josh Howard, Morehouse College
Fred Jackson, Rhodes College
Cole Kennon, Middlebury College
David Reynolds, Florida International University
Wesley Walker, Georgia Tech
Dante Wynn, U.S. Air Force Academy
2020Cal Archdeacon, Amherst College
Gerard Bullock, University of Dayton
Evan Cooley, Furman University
Austin Henderson, University of Minnesota
Caleb Horton, Austin Peay State University
Keshawn Lawrence, University of Tennessee
Ethan Sipe, Dartmouth College
William Wright, University of Tennessee
2021
Bryce Edmondson, University of Memphis
Andre Turrentine, Ohio State University