Ensights Magazine

Core Skills in the Classroom: The Mastery Transcript Consortium

Bobby Mirzaie, Director of Curriculum and Instruction
Grading Ahead of the Curve: Skills-Based Assessments and the Mastery Transcript Consortium
As an avid collector of baseball cards in my youth, I can recall the excitement when opening each pack containing a few dozen cards. While chewing the piece of pink bubblegum from the pack, I would spend countless hours reviewing the profiles of every player. This exercise would prompt many questions. What information highlights certain trends in a player’s development? Which players had a breakout year? How do the statistics across various categories tell a cohesive story about the player’s abilities, growth, and potential? Well after the bubblegum became stale, I would still revel in the joyful exploration of each player’s unique talents as displayed from one card to the next. 
What if every student could receive a similar portrait, one that provides a visual display of the academic skills, character traits, and meaningful learning attributes developed through the journey of a K-12 education?
This is the question we are exploring at Ensworth alongside 160 forward-thinking schools across the globe in a new group called The Mastery Transcript Consortium (MTC), which “is organized around the development of creating an alternative model of assessment, crediting, and transcript generation. This model calls for students to demonstrate a mastery of skills, knowledge, and habits of mind by presenting evidence that is assessed in line with a school’s specific standards of mastery.”
Our participation with MTC offers an opportunity to renew our commitment to a skills-based approach to teaching and learning. We are engaging in robust conversations about how our current practices shape and inspire meaningful learning for our students. We are reflecting on how we articulate the skills mastered by each individual student. We are asking what information is embedded within traditional numerical and letter grades. Our independent school peers within MTC are engaging in similar conversations. Ultimately, we hope that our collaboration and partnership with MTC can lead toward the long-term goal of inventing a shared, but not identical, tool to illustrate each student’s academic growth, character development, and an overall skills profile at key benchmarks during the educational journey.
Engaging conversations are taking place between MTC and college admissions deans, which have produced several concerns about the relationship between preparation for college and college admissions. Colleges are seeking students who are more equipped with abilities that align with our own Core Skills. MTC schools are wary about distilling all of a student’s knowledge, skills, and learning traits into a single number or letter grade. While students may earn an identical grade in a course, their development of unique skills can be quite different. Also, colleges are seeking students with key character traits, such as grit, curiosity, and optimism that are not explicitly articulated on a current high school transcript.
There will be significant work ahead for us and our MTC partners, as we are still in the early stages of an exciting and unpredictable process of designing a new high school transcript. We continue to work our way through challenging questions such as: What is our current skill-based approach to learning now, and what do we want it to look like in the future? What do we want every student to demonstrate at key junctures in the K-12 Ensworth experience? How should assessment and grading practices evolve to support students’ development of the Core Skills and other mission-driven qualities? We will devote much time toward digging into these questions with various experiments, pilot testing, and ongoing forward thinking. Stay tuned!

List of 5 news stories.

  • high school harkness

    Experiential Learning in the High School: Harkness on Your Feet

    One of the challenges that we face as a department is keeping alive in our high school students the joy of reading instilled by the lower/middle school faculty. High school students are increasingly focused on the grade (or the “points”) offered by an assignment, and it’s difficult to get them to slow down and focus on reading as exploration, as a puzzle to be unlocked, or as play.
    Read More
  • My First Book Haiti

    Experiential Learning in the High School: My First Book

    The “My First Book” project began after I attended my first Social Issues Conference where the Restore LaVi session piqued my interest. Former parent Diana Day-Cartee and her daughter, Ali Cartee ’18, had been volunteering in Haiti for a while with restavecs, or child slaves.
    Read More
  • Kindergarten Science

    Experiential Learning in the Lower School

    In ways both big and small, our Lower School teachers are bringing curricular content to life through immersive activities that offer students the opportunity to go far beyond retention of facts and figures and to fully absorb the knowledge that they set out to discover. The following examples illustrate this approach and represent only the tip of the iceberg that is experiential learning at Ensworth.
    Read More
  • Grade 6 Museum Project

    Experiential Learning in the Middle School: Grade 6 Museum Project

    All Grade 6 History classes, taught by Ruby Cortner, Maurice Hopkins, and J.K. Scott, brought wonders of the ancient world to life by creating a pop-up museum event in Patton Hall for the entire Lower/Middle School community this fall.
    Read More
  • responsive classroom

    Responsive Classroom

    Children are more comfortable and confident in engaging in active learning when they are in an environment that fosters social and emotional understanding and competence. Responsive Classroom (RC) is an approach to teaching that employs thoughtful and proactive practices to create a safe and joyful classroom culture that is developmentally responsive to students’ strengths and needs.
    Read More